Nutley NJ Real Estate Market Report | The DeSilva Team
Free Home Valuation

Nutley, NJ — Single-Family Market Report

The Nutley Real Estate Market,
In Clear Numbers

YTD data through April 2026. Updated from GSMLS records so you can make smart, confident decisions.

$711K
Median Sale Price
27
Median Days on Market
102.7%
Median Sale-to-List
58%
Homes Sold Over Ask

Data pulled April 2026  ·  GSMLS  ·  Single-Family Homes

Market Inventory

Current Snapshot

Where things stand right now across active, pending, and recently sold properties.

15
Active Listings
Median ask: $749,999
Range: $480K – $1.8M
Competitive, constrained supply
22
Under Contract
High absorption rate
More homes in contract than active — a clear seller’s market signal
38
Sold YTD
Jan–Apr 2026
Avg sale price: $692,500
Closed: Jan 2 – Apr 10

Performance Metrics

What the Numbers Say

Median figures from 38 closed transactions this year, through April 10, 2026.

$711K
Median Sale Price
Range: $400K to $1.18M
27
Median Days on Market
Avg: 35 days — demand is swift
$455
Median Price / Sq Ft
Based on homes with sq ft data
102.7%
Median SP/LP Ratio
Avg 105.3% — multiple offers common

Price Distribution

Where Homes Are Selling

Breakdown of the 38 closed sales by final price range, YTD 2026.

Closed Sales by Price Range — January through April 2026

Under $400K
2
$400–$500K
3
$500–$600K
10
$600–$700K
3
$700–$800K
12
$800–$900K
4
$900K–$1M
2
Over $1M
2

Recent Sales

8 Most Recent Closed Sales

The latest transactions on record in GSMLS, sorted by close date.

Address Sale Price List Price Beds/Baths Sq Ft DOM SP/LP Closed Style
31 Emily Ave $615,000 $596,000 3 / 1.1 — 20 103% 04/10/26 Colonial
612 Passaic Ave $712,000 $590,000 3 / 2.0 — 8 121% 04/07/26 Colonial
238 Rutgers Pl $1,175,000 $974,900 5 / 2.1 2,532 16 121% 04/02/26 Colonial
3 White Ter $750,000 $749,999 3 / 2.1 — 46 100% 03/31/26 Colonial
180 Highfield Ln $910,000 $790,000 4 / 2.1 — 16 115% 03/30/26 Cape Cod
70 Kierstead Ave $400,000 $350,000 2 / 2.0 800 35 114% 03/20/26 Ranch
318 Park Ave $750,000 $649,900 3 / 1.1 — 12 115% 03/13/26 Colonial
190 Conover Ave $585,000 $585,000 3 / 2.0 — 141 100% 03/09/26 Colonial

Currently Active

Homes For Sale Right Now

15 single-family homes currently on the market in Nutley as of this data pull.

294 Park Ave
$480,000
2 bd 1.1 ba
16 days on market Colonial Listed 03/30/26
401 Walnut St
$549,900
3 bd 1.1 ba
7 days on market Colonial Listed 04/08/26
169 Oak Ridge Ave
$675,000
3 bd 1.1 ba
7 days on market Colonial Listed 04/08/26
71 Spring St
$695,000
4 bd 2.0 ba 4,700 sqft
133 days on market Colonial Listed 12/03/25
288 Harrison St
$699,000
4 bd 2.1 ba
35 days on market Colonial Listed 03/11/26
78 Hastings Ave
$699,000
3 bd 2.0 ba 2,200 sqft
18 days on market Split-Level Listed 03/28/26
51 Cedar St
$699,999
3 bd 1.1 ba
12 days on market Cape Cod Listed 04/03/26
387 Passaic Ave
$749,999
3 bd 2.1 ba
8 days on market Cape Cod Listed 04/07/26
68 Cathedral Ave
$750,000
4 bd 1.2 ba 8,120 sqft lot
29 days on market Colonial Listed 03/17/26
41 High St
$775,000
3 bd 2.1 ba
69 days on market Ranch/Raised Listed 02/05/26
22 Vine St
$790,000
3 bd 3.1 ba 2,725 sqft
7 days on market Colonial Listed 04/08/26
81 Hastings Ave
$1,089,000
3 bd 3.0 ba
20 days on market Half-Duplex Listed 03/26/26
138 Spatz Ave
$1,189,000
5 bd 4.1 ba
8 days on market Colonial Listed 04/07/26
36 Harrison St
$1,699,000
8 bd 4.0 ba 4,180 sqft
41 days on market Half-Duplex Listed 03/05/26
18 Stockton Pl
$1,800,000
6 bd 3.1 ba 4,100 sqft
157 days on market Colonial Listed 11/09/25

Work With Us

What’s Your Home Worth in This Market?

With homes consistently selling above asking price, knowing your home’s true value matters. We provide accurate, data-driven valuations with no pressure — just clarity.

Visit thedesilvateam.com →

Request a Free Home Valuation